If anyone posts one, they are either at the top, or not very smart. The important thing on the links would not be the ships counts/fleet composition, but rather the location and times...

i agree with kick on this one

Good old suggestion, never reached a conclusion. Poll is still here so let's see what you think about it now.

Forum rules usually state to not allow information such as co-ords and techs being given out. Posting CRs shows the three most important things a player has: times, fleet comp and location of launch. If this were implemented, i personally would still only show the results in my CRs personally. That being said it would be interesting, although it would not be of a high priority at all in my opinion.

I say no

Kk, i see where some are coming from. We need a CR converter that converts it to a format that doesn't show date/time, maybe coords, wsa. I definitely think the fleets should be able to be posted though.Maybe just show initial and final ships/defense. Or show the waves of combat in a simplified format without coords and times.

If ships were shown, people could already deduct a minimum tech and shipyard level for the loser and winner. I say no to this and think the current combat reports are fine.

Shipyard level has nothing to do with combat. The only thing would be ship types they have, but it's possible they have a split feet. Not to mention 95% of UoH posts are huge hits on experienced players who already have all ship types.

I think a few people are missing the point. The question is should it be allowed, not should it be required.

And it's because of that I say the same thing I said when this poll first came out: yes.